The sense or nonsense of regional aviation
Posted: Fri Nov 04, 2016 10:36 am
Here in germany, and I'm sure in many other countries as well, the national airline offers domestic flights.
Example: Airline: Lufthansa
Departure: Frankfurt am Main
Destination: Munich
Competitor: DB (train)
Start time: 12:00
Competition of time, money and enviromental footprint:
[b]Let's start with taking the train. [/b]From the city center you are usually in a few minutes at the main train station, so you can take the train from 12:20 to 16:11. -> At 16:11 you are at your destination
Price: 82€
see: https://reiseauskunft.bahn.de/bin/query ... 1&OK#focus
CO2 (Environmental Footprint): https://reiseauskunft.bahn.de/bin/query ... playMode=p
2,8g
[b]Now taking the airplane[/b]
You have to get to the airport: so take the train from 12:10 to 12:22 (13€). Usually you have to be at the airport 2 hours before departure, so the first plane fitting for you would be 14:15 to 15:15 (365,15€). Then you are at the airport of Munich. After 15 mins you have your baggage and 5 minutes later you have walked through the airport to the train station. It's 15:35 now. So, to get to the Munich city centre, you can take the train again: 15:36 to 16:20 (Price: ?) Overall price about 380€.
CO2 (Environmental Footprint): https://reiseauskunft.bahn.de/bin/query ... playMode=p
114,3g
Soooo, let's compare:
Time advantage of airplane over train: -9 min (you're coming 9 minutes later)
Price advantage of airplane over train: -298€ (you're paying 298€ more)
CO2 advantage of airplane over train: -111g (you're producing around 110 g of CO2 more).
Why can such connections work??
Example: Airline: Lufthansa
Departure: Frankfurt am Main
Destination: Munich
Competitor: DB (train)
Start time: 12:00
Competition of time, money and enviromental footprint:
[b]Let's start with taking the train. [/b]From the city center you are usually in a few minutes at the main train station, so you can take the train from 12:20 to 16:11. -> At 16:11 you are at your destination
Price: 82€
see: https://reiseauskunft.bahn.de/bin/query ... 1&OK#focus
CO2 (Environmental Footprint): https://reiseauskunft.bahn.de/bin/query ... playMode=p
2,8g
[b]Now taking the airplane[/b]
You have to get to the airport: so take the train from 12:10 to 12:22 (13€). Usually you have to be at the airport 2 hours before departure, so the first plane fitting for you would be 14:15 to 15:15 (365,15€). Then you are at the airport of Munich. After 15 mins you have your baggage and 5 minutes later you have walked through the airport to the train station. It's 15:35 now. So, to get to the Munich city centre, you can take the train again: 15:36 to 16:20 (Price: ?) Overall price about 380€.
CO2 (Environmental Footprint): https://reiseauskunft.bahn.de/bin/query ... playMode=p
114,3g
Soooo, let's compare:
Time advantage of airplane over train: -9 min (you're coming 9 minutes later)
Price advantage of airplane over train: -298€ (you're paying 298€ more)
CO2 advantage of airplane over train: -111g (you're producing around 110 g of CO2 more).
Why can such connections work??